In Trump’s Carroll appeal, immunity coming back to Supreme Court

Donald Trump has had a Supreme Court petition pending for months in one of the defamation cases he lost against writer E. Jean Carroll. He’s about to file another one — and it’s going to involve presidential immunity.

This Video Is Trending Right Now →

The court doesn’t have to review either claim. But even if the justices deny review, Carroll won’t be able to collect on the millions of dollars in damages she won until then.

Of course, if the justices agree to review either or both of Trump’s appeals, then that will raise the question of whether the damages stand, a question that wouldn’t be answered until the justices rule in that hypothetical scenario. It takes four justices to grant review of a petition.

The high court isn’t on a deadline to decide whether to take up either appeal. But here is where they both stand.

The already pending petition is for the case in which a New York City jury awarded $5 million in damages in 2023 after finding that Trump sexually abused Carroll in 1996 and defamed her in 2022. He argues that the trial judge wrongly admitted evidence against him, including the “Access Hollywood” tape in which he bragged about grabbing women by their genitals. He argues that his appeal gives the justices a chance to resolve important questions about how courts use evidence. Opposing review, Carroll’s lawyers argue that there’s no good reason for the justices to get involved.

Though the petition has been pending for months, it hasn’t made it to the court’s private conference where the justices decide which new cases to take up. The court keeps rescheduling it. It’s unclear why. But the bottom line is that the court hasn’t yet decided whether to grant or deny review in the $5 million case. The next chance for the justices to consider that petition is at their next conference on May 14.

Barring an urgent situation that these cases don’t present, any new appeals granted review at this point in the court’s term wouldn’t be argued until the following term, which starts in October.

Meanwhile, a petition in the other case, in which Carroll won $83.3 million in defamation damages, is on its way to the justices. That’s according to a new court filing from the president that described the petition as “upcoming.” That filing was lodged Tuesday in the New York-based federal appeals court where he has failed to overturn his trial court losses.